Members of a state Senate committee voted unanimously Thursday to stop a bill that would have changed the public records law to allow state agencies to keep secret the names and résumés of most job applicants.
The Senate Public Affairs Committee voted 5-0 to table Senate Bill 93, sponsored by Sen. George Muñoz, D-Gallup.
The bill would have restricted public access to most applications for government jobs. If an applicant didn’t become a finalist for a position, the application would be kept secret forever.
“Some positions merit disclosure,” said Sen. Bill O’Neill, D-Albuquerque, a committee member.
Applications for many government jobs in New Mexico are public records because of a 2009 state Court of Appeals decision that forced the city of Farmington to release all applications for its city manager job.
But the public records law doesn’t cover candidates for presidencies of state universities. A separate law allows universities to keep the field of candidates secret. Typically, only the names of finalists are made public.
Muñoz argued that disclosing names in the early stages of a hiring process dissuades many qualified people from applying.
Nick Estes, former general counsel of The University of New Mexico, agreed. He said 32 states have laws that allow government to withhold information about public job applicants.
“What the press would like to do is second-guess whether the best person is getting the job,” he said. “The cost [of disclosure] is that you lose a lot of good people.”
Also testifying in favor of the bill was former New Mexico Gov. Garrey Carruthers, now president of New Mexico State University. “It’s hard to argue against transparency in government,” he said. But “non-disclosure will cause the pool to be more robust.”
As a lawyer, state Rep. Jim Dines, R-Albuquerque, battled Estes in court over public information cases. Dines said there is no data that prove keeping the names of applicants secret improves the pool of candidates.
Former legislator and former University of New Mexico regent Jamie Koch of Santa Fe said he sponsored the state’s first public records bill in 1974. “Once you start amending [the Inspection of Public Records Act], you can’t stop it,” he said.
The bill, which was originally sponsored by Sen. Mary Kay Papen, D-Las Cruces, but later handed off to Muñoz, was an apparent response to a lawsuit from NMPolitics.net seeking the release of all applications last year from Las Cruces’ search for a new city manager. The city released some but withheld dozens of others. That lawsuit is pending.
Peter St. Cyr, executive director of the New Mexico Foundation for Open Government, told the committee that the bill was an “ill-conceived idea.”
“These are public jobs. These people are applying for the privilege of working for us,” St. Cyr said.